Testimonials
Dined on 04/29/2011
LOVE the new look!!! Warm, cozy, inviting and very NEW YORK!!! I ordered the steak special, which I never think to order at Castalia and it was out of this world. As good if not better than the best steak houses. They now offer baked pots which was an unexpected treat. They were very busy but honored all reservation times. Truly a special place. Will be back soon.
Dined on 04/13/2011
Truly enjoyed the evening. Could not be any better. The service was attentive yet not intrusive, the owner and his wife oversee every detail and are intuitive and available. The menu accommodates every mood and if not seen on the menu they will attempt to prepare it for you if the ingredients are on hand.
Dined on 04/22/2011
Friendly service and wonderful food! We had a great meal and the best martini I ever had
Dined on 04/20/2011
Never heard of the place before, and picked the restaurant after reading very strong reviews on this site. Food was very good, and service was impeccable anf friendly. Impressed with the meal overall, especially given the location. When the GPS led us to a strip mall in a location that was not far from a much less desirable neighborhood, we had our doubts... but happy in the end that we stuck to the plan and had a very nice meal. We'll probably go back, but find a less direct, but safer, route to take (GPS took us straight through downtown Paterson).
Dined on 04/16/2011
Food was excellent, bordering on excellent. Service was a little slow and not very attentive. Tables are small, two at a table set for four was comfortable.
Dined on 04/16/2011
Went here for my husband's birthday. From the minute we arrived to we left he felt special and appreciated. Food is awesome. Try the calamari with pepper sauce. The raspberry torte and the citrus lemon cake were awesome. This was our first time here and we will be back again. Highly recommend.
